A constitution on paper is only as real as the institutions that run it daily. Working of Institutions — Democratic Politics I, Chapter 4 — shows how a major policy decision travels through India’s government: from an office memorandum to Parliament’s debates to the courts. These working of institutions class 9 notes cover the three great institutions — the political executive and legislature, the President, and the judiciary — with the Mandal Commission story that ties them together.
This chapter completes the civics arc that began with our Civics Class 9 Ch 1 notes and Constitutional Design Class 9 notes, and it previews the structures you will compare in the Class 10 civics notes on power sharing and federalism.
Working of Institutions Class 9 Notes: The Mandal Story
On 13 August 1990, the Government of India issued an order — Office Memorandum No. 36012/31/90 — reserving 27% of posts in government services and public sector undertakings for the Socially and Educationally Backward Classes (SEBC). Behind that one-page order lay a decade-long process:
In 1979, the Janata Party government appointed the Second Backward Classes Commission, headed by B.P. Mandal, to determine the criteria for identifying socially and educationally backward classes and recommend steps for their advancement. The Commission reported in 1980, recommending 27% reservation in government jobs for these classes, among other steps. Through the 1980s, Parliament and newspapers debated the report; parties promised implementation in election campaigns. In the 1989 Lok Sabha election, the Janata Dal promised in its manifesto to implement the Mandal recommendations; after forming the government, Prime Minister V.P. Singh announced the decision in Parliament, the Union Cabinet approved it, and the Department of Personnel and Training issued the order.
The decision triggered nationwide debate and protests, including self-immolations by students, and was challenged in the Supreme Court. In the landmark Indira Sawhney case (1992), the court upheld the reservation order as valid but directed modifications — creamy-layer exclusion among the backward classes — and the government implemented it in modified form. This one story demonstrates all three institutions at work: an expert commission, the political executive deciding, Parliament debating, citizens reacting, and the judiciary reviewing. In examinations, it is the standing example for how decisions move through institutions rather than through one person’s command.
Parliament: Why We Need It and What It Does
Parliament is the final authority for making laws in India — no law can be passed or significantly changed without its approval. It also controls the government’s money (taxes and budgets), is the highest forum of discussion and debate on public issues, and can summon information, question ministers (Question Hour) and remove a government through a no-confidence motion. An institution like Parliament is needed because decisions affecting everyone must be deliberated and approved by the people’s representatives, not merely announced.
Parliament consists of the President and two Houses: the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) — the upper house, representing the states, whose members serve six-year terms with one-third retiring every two years — and the Lok Sabha (House of the People) — directly elected by the people for five years. Money matters and confidence in the government tilt towards the Lok Sabha: a money bill can originate only in the Lok Sabha, and the Council of Ministers survives only while it commands the Lok Sabha’s confidence. That is why the Lok Sabha is called the more powerful house in financial and executive-control matters, while the Rajya Sabha protects states’ interests and revises legislation with a slower, more permanent body.
The Political Executive: Prime Minister and Council of Ministers
The executive is the institution that implements laws and policies. It has two layers: the political executive (elected leaders — ministers — who are answerable to the people and take the final policy decisions) and the permanent executive or civil services (officials appointed on merit through examinations like the UPSC, who work under the ministers and manage day-to-day administration). The political executive is more powerful than the permanent one: an officer with technical knowledge advises, but the minister — backed by electoral legitimacy and final decision rights — decides.
The Prime Minister is the head of the government and the real centre of executive power. The President appoints as PM the leader of the majority party or coalition in the Lok Sabha (who must prove majority support). The PM allocates portfolios to ministers, chairs cabinet meetings, coordinates ministries, and leads the government in Parliament and in elections. The Council of Ministers is the body of all ministers, in three ranks:
- Cabinet Ministers — senior leaders holding the top ministries, who together form the Cabinet, the inner decision circle of usually 20–25 members
- Ministers of State with independent charge — in charge of smaller ministries, attending Cabinet meetings when their ministry’s matters are discussed
- Ministers of State — attached to cabinet ministers, assisting them in their departments
Governance normally works on collective responsibility: the entire council is responsible to the Lok Sabha and falls together if a no-confidence motion passes.
Coalition governments since 1989 have complicated this picture: PMs of coalitions must accommodate partners’ demands, consult allies before major decisions, and sometimes face public vetoes from alliance partners — a common essay angle on how the PM’s authority, though constitutionally vast, is politically negotiated.
The President: Head of State, Not Head of Government
The President of India is the head of the State — the formal, nominal head in whose name the government runs, resembling the position of the British monarch. The President is not directly elected by the people, but by an electoral college of elected MPs and MLAs, for a five-year term. All governmental activities, laws, major appointments (Chief Justice, judges, Governors, Election Commissioners, ambassadors) and international treaties happen in the President’s name — the supreme commander of the defence forces issues orders as President — yet the real decisions are made by the Council of Ministers led by the PM. Constitutional provisions are clear that the President is bound to act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers.
The President’s discretion is narrow but real: when no party or alliance has a clear majority after an election, the President decides whom to invite to form the government; the President can also ask the Council of Ministers to reconsider advice (once), and can return a bill for reconsideration (once) — if Parliament passes it again, the President must sign. Ordinary bills need the President’s assent to become law; money bills cannot be returned. The office’s prestige, continuity (the President stays above parties after election) and emergency powers (Article 352 etc., exercised formally on advice) make the President the republic’s constitutional anchor rather than its pilot.
The Judiciary: Independent and Powerful
India has an integrated judiciary: a single system of courts enforcing both central and state laws, with the Supreme Court at the apex, High Courts in the states, and district and subordinate courts below. The Supreme Court also settles disputes between the central and state governments (federal disputes) and between states.
Judicial independence is protected structurally: judges are appointed by the President on a collegium-informed process and cannot be removed by the executive or legislature — removal requires an impeachment motion passed by a special majority in both Houses for proven misbehaviour or incapacity. Judges’ salaries are charged on the Consolidated Fund and not voted upon, their conduct cannot be discussed in legislatures except during removal proceedings, and they enjoy security of tenure until retirement age (65 for the Supreme Court, 62 for High Courts).
Its powers include judicial review — the courts can strike down any law or executive action that violates the Constitution (as the Supreme Court did in part in the Mandal judgement itself) — and enforcement of fundamental rights: any citizen can approach the Supreme Court (Article 32) or a High Court (Article 226) directly when rights are violated. Through Public Interest Litigation (PIL), even third parties can approach courts on matters of public concern, extending the judiciary’s reach to issues like pollution and bonded labour. The chapter’s counsel of balance: the judiciary is powerful but functions within the Constitution, and its disputes with the other organs (over appointments or jurisdiction) are themselves settled through constitutional processes.
A useful way to remember the three institutions’ relationship is the flow of a single day: the Cabinet meets in the morning and clears a bill; Parliament debates and passes it in the afternoon session; the President signs it in the evening; a citizen challenges it in court the following week; and the court decides whether it survives. No institution completes this circuit alone — each one’s power is defined by where the others stop it, and that mutual checking is the chapter’s deepest pattern, more important than any individual list of functions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Mandal Commission, and why is it discussed here?
A commission (1979–80) under B.P. Mandal that recommended 27% reservation in government jobs for socially and educationally backward classes. The chapter uses its journey — recommendation, debate, executive order, court review — to show institutions working.
Why is the political executive more powerful than the permanent executive?
Because ministers are elected representatives answerable to the people, and the Constitution gives them the final say in policy. Civil servants advise and implement, but they work under the ministers’ direction.
Can the President reject the advice of the Council of Ministers?
No, not finally. The President can ask for reconsideration once and can delay, but must act on the advice tendered again. The President’s genuine discretion applies mainly when no party has a clear majority after elections.
How is the independence of the judiciary protected?
Judges’ appointments do not depend on the government’s pleasure; they can be removed only by a difficult impeachment process; salaries are not voted annually by Parliament; and their conduct cannot be debated in legislatures.
Conclusion
Working of Institutions is a flow chapter: decisions move from commissions to cabinets, memoranda to Parliament, protests to courtrooms. Learn the Mandal timeline, the two-House contrast, the PM–President distinction, and the independence safeguards of the judiciary, and the whole machinery of Indian democracy reads like one connected machine — which is precisely how the Constitution designed it in 1950. Verify names and dates once in the NCERT Democratic Politics I book before your final revision.


